Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I marked an unwanted gift as faulty because I wanted a different return outcome

Confessions category photographConfessions

The return form asked what was wrong with the item. I selected "faulty." Nothing was wrong with it. I didn't like it.

I'd read that the shop handled unwanted gifts differently and wanted the more favourable outcome. Now I've had a confirmation, but the return hasn't been settled. I'm considering saying I selected the wrong box by accident.

That would be another false account. How do I correct this with the shop without bringing the gift giver into an explanation of how much I disliked their present? I want to sort out the return, but I can't keep treating the result I prefer as a reason the item should acquire a defect.

Discussion

5 community replies

Contact the shop and say you knowingly gave the wrong return reason. Ask them to correct the record before processing it further. Don't call it a mistaken click when you remember choosing the option for the outcome it offered.

You can keep the explanation relevant: the item is unwanted, not faulty. The shop doesn't need a ranking of the gift or a story about the giver's taste. Give the actual information needed to apply its return policy.

Be prepared for the honest return to have a different outcome. Correcting the claim isn't an arrangement in which the shop must preserve the benefit you sought. Ask what options actually apply rather than announcing the remedy you think would make your honesty worthwhile.

There may be a separate question about what the gift giver needs to know, especially if their purchase details or involvement are required. Find out the real process first. Don't recruit them into repeating the fault claim so you can avoid an awkward conversation.

And don't give them the full burden of correcting the shop if your own request started it. You can explain the return reason yourself and ask what information is needed. If their involvement is necessary, be clear about why rather than making a request that leaves them supporting a story they don't know is false.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions