Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

I'm listed as a co-author, but I haven't seen the final paper

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

The project lead sent me an authorship form and asked me to approve it before submission. I helped acquire and analyse data, but I haven't seen the final manuscript.

The submission checklist refers to ICMJE criteria. When I asked for the paper, I was told the senior authors had handled the writing and that my name was recognition for the data work. I want that contribution recognised. I don't want to approve a version I haven't read or misunderstand the responsibility attached to the byline.

How do I ask for the opportunity to review and contribute without sounding as though I'm rejecting the credit or questioning everyone else's work?

Discussion

5 community replies

Under the ICMJE criteria, authorship includes final approval and accountability as well as the relevant contribution to the work. Ask for the manuscript and time to review it before approving the form. Data work should not be treated as a reason to bypass the other criteria where that framework applies. ICMJE recommendations.

Be specific about what you're requesting: the version intended for submission, the contribution statement and an opportunity to raise questions about your work and the wider account. You can want appropriate credit and still take the approval seriously.

If the timetable is the difficulty, ask the lead to address it rather than signing first and reading later. If the disagreement continues, use the institution's authorship or research-integrity process. Keep the request about participation and responsibilities, not an accusation you cannot substantiate.

It would also be unfair to deny someone authorship because they haven't reviewed a paper nobody has allowed them to see.

ICMJE explicitly warns against excluding contributors by denying them the opportunity to meet the review and approval criteria. Someone who meets the substantial-contribution criterion should have that opportunity. Ask to take part, rather than accepting a false choice between signing unread and silently giving up recognition. ICMJE recommendations.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work