Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

I'm judging an award, and my own project is among the entries

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

I opened the judging pack and recognised a project I'd helped deliver for my company. I hadn't submitted the entry and didn't know it was in the competition.

I told the organiser. They said I could leave that entry unscored and carry on judging the others in its category. I'm not sure that resolves it: scoring the competing projects could still affect where ours finishes.

I was pleased to be invited onto the panel, and I don't want my team excluded because I accepted. I also don't want other entrants to discover the connection afterwards and wonder about the results. What would you ask the organiser to decide before continuing?

Discussion

5 community replies

Explain your actual involvement in the project, not just the company connection, and ask for a decision under the award's conflict rules. You have raised the issue; the organiser now needs to consider the whole affected category, including your scores for competitors.

Your team's eligibility and your judging role are separate questions for the organiser. Don't offer to withdraw the project on colleagues' behalf or reassure them it is definitely safe to remain. Ask who can make those decisions independently.

You could offer to step away from this category while remaining available for unrelated categories, if the organiser's rules allow it. That may preserve a useful role without requiring you to make judgments that could influence your own project's result.

Skipping your own entry doesn't remove the concern about the other marks. Even an honest judge might find it hard to separate knowing their own project's constraints from evaluating somebody else's finished presentation.

That's why the organiser should consider recusal from the affected category, rather than treating the blank score as automatically sufficient. Ask them to record the connection and the agreed handling before scoring continues. An independent decision gives everyone a clearer account than an informal assurance that you'll be fair.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work