Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I kept putting the costume back on my dog because I wanted the photograph

Confessions category photographConfessions

My dog pawed at the costume and walked away. I put it back on twice. When my niece asked whether he wanted it off, I said he was just being camera-shy.

The costume is off now, and I won't repeat the session. At the time I kept looking at whether the picture would be funny instead of whether he was comfortable. I sent the best frame to the family chat with "He loves dressing up."

That caption isn't something the photograph established. I watched the attempts to get away and edited them out of the story.

Should I correct the message as well as changing what I do? I don't want my niece to learn that an animal's discomfort can be relabelled as a cute personality trait when the adults want a picture.

Discussion

5 community replies

Correct the caption and tell your niece she was right to question continuing. You don't need to announce a diagnosis of what the dog felt. You can say he tried to remove it and leave, and you should have stopped instead of putting it back.

RSPCA Australia's costume guidance advises observing the animal and not using costumes when there is obvious discomfort, including attempts to remove them. It also warns that apparent stillness can be misleading. A single cute frame isn't an assessment of this dog's welfare during the session.

The change you describe now is useful. Keep it about your choices rather than blaming the costume, the camera or relatives who like the photograph. None of them made you continue after noticing him trying to leave.

If you still want pictures, let them record something he is already doing comfortably rather than finding a less obvious way to hold the pose. Don't make your niece responsible for inventing a version of the costume session that would redeem the first one.

Yes. You can thank her for speaking up without giving her the job of supervising the next photo. Make the decision to leave costumes out yourself. The useful lesson is that the adult listened and changed the activity, not that she must keep protesting until an adult takes the discomfort seriously.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions