Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I kept my friend's mistake quiet, then brought it up when she wouldn't swap a shift

Confessions category photographConfessions

My friend forgot to collect a key for a volunteer event. I managed to borrow another one before anyone arrived, and told her I wouldn't make an issue of it. Nobody else needed to know for the event to go ahead.

A few weeks later I asked her to swap a shift. She said she couldn't. I replied, “After I saved you with the key? Maybe the organiser should know how reliable you really are.”

I haven't told the organiser, but I can't pretend it was just a reminder of a nice thing I did. I wanted her to think refusing me could cost her. She said she'd rather I had raised the key problem honestly at the time than kept it to hold over her.

I do feel that I help her more than she helps me. Now I can't raise that without it sounding like a defence of the threat. How do I withdraw it clearly, and is there any way to discuss reciprocity later without suggesting she can earn my silence by being a better friend?

Discussion

5 community replies

Withdraw the link between the two events explicitly: “You don't owe me a shift swap for that, and I shouldn't have threatened to embarrass you.” An apology that only says you were stressed leaves her wondering whether the threat will return next time she says no.

You don't actually know what a yes would have cost her. “Couldn't” might mean a commitment she has no wish to explain. A favour you did freely doesn't give you first claim on her next available hours.

She has identified a real difference between reporting a practical problem and keeping it as leverage. For future volunteer mistakes, agree with the team how problems should be raised. Don't appoint yourself the private keeper of her record and then decide when to release it.

Friendship still needs some willingness to help each other. You don't have to agree to every future favour just because you handled this badly. But the key incident can't be the argument that wins a conversation about feeling unsupported.

Yes. You can change what you offer going forward without attaching a penalty to her refusal. If you later discuss feeling unsupported, use current examples and ask what each of you can realistically do. First give her space to decide whether she trusts your apology.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions