Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

I keep giving career advice, then feel annoyed when my colleague chooses differently

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

A colleague asks me to read applications and talk through job options. I like helping, but I've noticed that I feel irritated when they choose a different approach after our conversation.

They don't report to me. They thank me, and they haven't promised to follow my advice. Last week I spent an evening reviewing an application, then caught myself treating their decision not to use my suggested emphasis as proof the time was wasted.

I want to be a useful colleague without quietly turning help into a request for obedience. How do I manage the time I give and the expectations I haven't actually said aloud?

Discussion

5 community replies

You've identified an expectation that wasn't part of the request. Ask what kind of help they want and offer only what you can give without needing your preferred answer adopted. Reviewing an application doesn't transfer the decision to you.

Limit the commitment before you begin. You might be willing to discuss one question or review a section, rather than spend another evening on the whole application. A smaller offer can be more sustainable than generous help followed by resentment.

You can ask which feedback was useful and what led them in another direction. Do that to understand, not to reopen the decision until they agree with you. They may be weighing information you don't have.

If the person keeps asking for substantial feedback and then disregards it, the helper is allowed to decide the arrangement isn't worthwhile.

Yes. You can decline or reduce the work without making future help conditional on obedience. Explain your capacity and what you can offer. That keeps the limit on your time clear while leaving the colleague responsible for their own career decisions.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work