Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I hid my good news because my friend was still waiting for hers

Confessions category photographConfessions

My friend asked whether I'd heard from the community choir. I said I was still waiting. My acceptance message was already on my phone.

We had both hoped to join. She was put on the waiting list, and I didn't want the next conversation to place us on different sides of something we'd been looking forward to together. Saying I had no news let me keep comforting her as though we were in exactly the same position.

The first rehearsal is next week. She has suggested we do something together that evening because neither of us has choir plans yet. I'm going to have to correct a lie I told in the name of sparing her feelings.

How do I share the acceptance without asking her to perform delight for me? I don't want to apologise for getting a place. I do need to apologise for deciding she couldn't handle knowing.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell her before answering the new invitation as though your evening is free. You can say you were accepted, felt awkward about the different results and gave her an untrue answer. Keep the apology attached to the lie rather than to your place in the choir.

She may be disappointed about her own wait and happy for you, or she may need some space from the topic. Let her have her actual reaction. Protecting her from the information also removed her chance to decide how she wanted to respond.

You can still care about her disappointment without claiming the same situation. Ask whether she'd like to talk about it or do something unrelated. Don't require the conversation to become a celebration of your news immediately.

If she wants to hear about rehearsal later, share it. If she doesn't yet, respect that without keeping your participation secret again. There is room between a detailed report and pretending you never received an acceptance.

That middle ground works through an honest question rather than your prediction of what she can bear. She can change her mind about hearing choir stories over time. Your job is to stop supplying false facts to preserve a version of togetherness that has already changed.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions