Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I handed back a borrowed bicycle without mentioning the brake problem I'd noticed

Confessions category photographConfessions

"All good?" my friend asked when I returned his bicycle. I said yes. On the way home, the brake lever had pulled much farther than I expected and the bike hadn't slowed as it had earlier.

I stopped riding and walked the rest of the way. At his door I suddenly worried he'd think I'd damaged it, so I said nothing. I don't know what caused the change or when the fault began.

I've now called, described what happened and asked him not to ride it until it's been professionally checked and any necessary repair is done. He's keeping it off the road. He also knows I noticed before returning it.

The safety warning shouldn't have waited for me to find a comfortable explanation. How do I discuss the inspection and possible repair without either denying responsibility for something I might have caused or claiming certainty about a cause I don't know?

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep the two admissions clear: you noticed the change while using the bike, and you concealed it at the handover. You can apologise for the concealment with certainty. You don't yet have the same certainty about the mechanical cause, and an honest account doesn't require inventing one.

NHTSA's bicycle guidance stresses riding a working bike with functioning brakes. Keeping this one unused pending a competent check is sensible. General guidance can't identify this fault or establish that a quick adjustment would make it safe; leave that assessment to the person inspecting it.

Not riding it again doesn't erase the withheld warning. You eventually supplied information he should have had at the door. Be glad he knows now without using that as a reason he shouldn't be upset about the delay. Let him describe the inconvenience rather than deciding what it cost him.

Ask your friend how he wants the inspection arranged before booking work on his bicycle. Offering to help with the cost is different from deciding the repair, the shop and the outcome for him. Your attempt to make amends shouldn't create another choice about his bike that he hasn't made.

And agree what you're offering before work begins, rather than announcing afterwards that you've paid and the matter is closed. An inspection may clarify the fault without answering every question about its history. The apology for withholding what you knew can remain clear even if that uncertainty remains.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions