Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I gave my friend's candle five stars without ever using it

Confessions category photographConfessions

A customer asked how long the scent lasted. I couldn't answer. I'd written that it filled the room beautifully, but the candle was still unopened.

My friend has launched a small online shop in the US. I bought one to support her, then left a glowing review because she was worried about having no reviews yet. She didn't ask me to invent an experience. I supplied that part myself.

Now she's shared a screenshot of my review on the shop's page. I want to withdraw what I made up without suggesting the candle is bad or making her feel I've withdrawn my support.

Do I tell her before removing the review? I don't want to wait for permission to correct it, but I also don't want her continuing to display words she doesn't yet know were invented.

Discussion

5 community replies

Correct or remove the false review promptly and tell your friend which claims you hadn't actually tested. She also needs to know about the screenshot so she can stop displaying it. You can inform her while making the correction; you don't need approval to stop presenting an invented experience.

The US FTC's endorsement guidance says endorsements must reflect actual experience and discusses disclosing relevant personal connections. Naming the friendship wouldn't make invented use truthful. That is the relevant guidance here, without trying to determine anyone's legal liability from this account.

Don't replace the five stars with a negative rating as a public confession. You don't yet have an experience of using the candle to report. A correction should withdraw your unsupported account, not imply the product performed badly.

Ask your friend what kind of support she'd welcome that doesn't involve a customer claim you can't make. You could still enjoy buying something or helping with a task. Avoid offering to try the candle only if she accepts that your eventual review will have to be positive.

And trying it later wouldn't make the earlier review accurate at the time you wrote it. If you eventually leave a genuine account, follow the site's rules and be clear about the connection. Don't treat a later test as a way to quietly restore the invented wording.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions