Politics · Advice & Questions · Oct 19

I dislike a shortlisted artist's politics. Is that relevant to the public mural?

Politics

The sketch shows migrating birds above the station entrance. The email opposing it shows photographs of the artist holding party leaflets.

I'm on a residents' advisory group commenting on designs for a publicly funded mural. I dislike the party the artist supports. The proposed mural doesn't include its logo or slogans, and the selection papers ask us to discuss the design, the site and the work required.

A fellow member says we should object because public money shouldn't help someone with those politics. Another says an artist's public conduct can never matter, which feels too broad to me. We haven't identified a concern about the submitted work itself.

How do I ask for a fair assessment without pretending that my reaction to the artist is neutral? What would make a concern about conduct relevant to this commission rather than a substitute for judging the design?

Discussion

2 community replies

@TheoInTransit

You've already identified your own dislike. Keep that separate from an assessment of the birds, site and brief. The leaflet photographs establish political participation in this scenario; they don't by themselves establish a problem with the proposed mural.

@maren17

"Conduct can never matter" is unnecessarily absolute. A commission could raise a specific concern about how work will be delivered or what the finished piece communicates. Ask the member making the objection to identify that connection rather than assume every objection to an artist is either valid or forbidden.

I dislike a shortlisted artist's politics. Is that relevant to the public mural?

Discussion

Join the discussion

More in Politics

An old political post of mine is still being shared, but I no longer hold that view

Can a residents' group call itself nonpartisan when its organisers belong to one party?

I removed a rude reply to my own political post but left a similar reply to someone else's

My brother told me his vote and now says I owe him mine