Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I discouraged my friend from applying because I wanted a place myself

Confessions category photographConfessions

My friend sent me the notice for a small printmaking course. I said it probably wouldn't be worth her Saturday mornings. Then I applied.

There were limited places, and I wanted one. I hadn't attended the course or found anything wrong with it. I used a confident opinion about its value to make my own competition feel smaller. She decided not to apply, and I've now been offered a place.

Yesterday she asked if I'd heard whether the course filled up. I said I wasn't sure. I can keep my acceptance quiet for a little while, but doing so would leave her with advice I didn't give honestly.

How do I tell her without offering my place as a dramatic repayment she never asked for? I want to admit the conflict I hid, not pretend the original suggestion was independent advice that happened to change.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell her you applied and that your earlier opinion wasn't based on knowledge of the course. The missing information is that you wanted a place yourself and allowed that interest to shape what you told her.

Don't assume she wants your place or that a transfer is possible. Start with the truth and let her decide what she wants to ask the organiser, if anything. Another unilateral decision wouldn't restore the choice you influenced.

You can apologise for the discouragement without describing her as someone who would certainly have been accepted. You don't know what would have happened. What you do know is that she made her decision with misleading advice from you.

If the course comes up again, separate your own preference from claims about its quality. 'I want to try it' is something you know. 'It isn't worth your time' was a verdict you supplied while concealing a reason to want her absent.

That distinction will matter beyond this course. When you share an opportunity you also want, disclose your interest before offering advice about whether someone else should pursue it. They can weigh your opinion with the context you kept private here.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions