Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I didn't want to hold my friend's newborn, and now I feel like a bad friend

Confessions category photographConfessions

My friend offered me her newborn to hold. I said, “No thanks, I'm nervous.” She looked hurt and said she thought I'd be excited.

I am excited for her. I enjoyed visiting and hearing how she's doing. I just didn't want to hold the baby. When she offered to help me try, I still said no.

Now I'm rehearsing a different explanation, like saying I had a sore arm. That wasn't true, and it would only postpone the same moment next visit.

Do I need to push myself to accept next time to show I care? Or can I explain that wanting to be her friend and wanting to hold her baby are different things without making the visit sound like a rejection?

Discussion

5 community replies

You can be warm about the baby without accepting every offer to hold them. “I loved seeing you both. I wasn't rejecting you; I was nervous about holding her.” You don't need a sore arm to make your answer legitimate.

Her reaction might have been disappointment in a moment she'd pictured sharing with you. That doesn't mean you were cruel, and it doesn't mean she was trying to force you. A gentle conversation can leave room for both feelings.

Keep showing interest in your friend as a person. Ask when she'd like another visit, listen to what she wants to talk about, or offer a specific practical kindness she actually wants. Holding the baby doesn't have to become the single test of whether the visit counted.

If you do want to get comfortable with holding the baby eventually, you can say that without committing to next time. But you shouldn't have to turn “not today” into a promise that she can claim on the next visit.

Yes. And if you don't currently want to work towards it, leave out “eventually” too. A reassuring explanation can be honest about where you are now. Inventing an injury or a future promise would just give both of you something inaccurate to plan around.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions