Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I correct our junior colleague in the group chat but give everyone else a private message

Confessions category photographConfessions

A junior colleague put a duplicate entry in our event checklist. I pointed it out in the team chat and explained how to avoid it. Later that week a more experienced colleague did the same thing. I sent them a quiet message.

The junior colleague asked why their mistake needed an audience. I said the reminder was useful for everyone. That could be true, but it wasn't a rule I applied to the other person.

I'm not their manager. I think I choose the public correction because I feel confident they won't challenge me. With the more experienced colleague, I worry about looking rude or pedantic.

The checklist is fixed. The unequal treatment isn't. Should I acknowledge it in the group where I made the correction, or start privately so I don't put the junior colleague through another public conversation? I want to stop doing this without asking them to teach me how to treat them fairly.

Discussion

5 community replies

Start by answering the question they asked you: “I handled the same mistake differently with someone else, and my explanation about a team reminder wasn't consistent.” Don't make them assemble a case proving that your tone felt different.

You can change your own approach without inventing a new team policy. If a general reminder is useful, write it as a general reminder and apply that approach consistently. If one person needs a small correction, consider whether a private message does the job.

Avoid announcing a long apology that identifies them as someone you embarrassed. That could give the original incident more attention. A private acknowledgement lets you ask whether there is a specific public impression they want corrected.

There may be a reason to correct something publicly if the whole team could act on the wrong information. Private messages aren't automatically the right answer. The inconsistency matters more than a universal ban on group corrections.

Agreed. Here the same checklist mistake got different treatment depending on who made it. You can explain a correction publicly when others need it while leaving out the lesson directed at a particular person's competence. The audience should serve the work, not your confidence about who will object.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions