Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I claimed to be a complete beginner because I wanted the class to be impressed

Confessions category photographConfessions

The tutor held up my painting and called it remarkable for a first attempt. I'd painted in a college art club for years and have done occasional projects since.

This workshop welcomes different levels. I told the tutor I'd never really tried because I wanted less pressure. When another student wished her first picture looked like mine, I said, "Just lucky." I liked being impressive without a history of practice.

The next session is tomorrow. How do I correct this without claiming to be an expert? I'm not, but I'm also not the beginner everyone has been comparing themselves with.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell the tutor before the session that you've painted before and understated your experience. Name the college club and later projects without trying to calculate your precise level. That gives the tutor useful information and stops the next demonstration being framed around a false first attempt.

The other student's comparison is a reason for a simple correction if it comes up again: "I should have said I've practised before." She doesn't need to hear you call yourself a fraud. She needs the missing context for the example she was comparing with her own work.

You can want help and still acknowledge experience. Saying you've painted before doesn't require you to perform as an expert for the rest of the course. Ask for instruction on the part you're finding difficult rather than using "complete beginner" as protection against any expectation.

Keep the painting's actual strengths separate from its false backstory. It may be a good picture, and you may still deserve encouragement. The compliment you can't fairly keep is the one based on this being your first attempt, not every positive response anyone had.

Yes. Correcting the history shouldn't become a demand that everyone withdraw praise or reassure you the picture still counts. Let the work remain on the table with its ordinary background of practice. That is a less dramatic, more accurate account than either prodigy or impostor.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions