Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I called it a friendly debate. My friend had only been saying what she enjoyed

Confessions category photographConfessions

My friend said she loves watching the same film every December. I asked why she'd waste an evening on something she already knew.

She said it was comforting. I asked whether comfort was really worth never discovering anything new. By then she wasn't telling a story about her winter routine. She was defending an evening in her own home.

I like debating ideas, and I thought that was what we were doing. She said, "Sometimes I'm just telling you what I like."

How do I show interest without turning every preference into a position she has to defend? I don't want conversation where we can only agree. I also don't want disagreement to be the entry fee for telling me about a pleasant evening.

Discussion

5 community replies

You skipped from her particular film to "never discovering anything new", which wasn't the life she described. Withdraw that larger claim. She can rewatch one film and still do other things you haven't discussed.

There are plenty of interested questions that don't demand a defence: what she enjoys about that film, whether she watches with anyone, what she notices on repeat viewings. Ask one you actually want answered, rather than disguising the same challenge in a gentler tone.

You don't have to agree that rewatching would suit you. You could say you tend to prefer a new film and leave room for her preference beside yours. A difference doesn't always need a winner before the conversation can continue.

If you want a debate about comfort and novelty, invite that conversation as a separate possibility. She may enjoy it another time. Beginning with "Why would you waste an evening?" made her own enjoyment the thing under examination before she had agreed to that format.

An invitation also needs an easy no. If she says she'd rather just tell you about the film, take that answer without calling her unwilling to think. Otherwise you've only moved the debate from her preference to whether she has a good enough reason not to debate it.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions