Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I called a guarantor request “just a reference” because I wanted my friend to say yes

Confessions category photographConfessions

My friend opened the tenancy paperwork and said, “This says guarantor. You told me they only needed a reference.”

We're in Scotland. I'd asked her to help with a rental application and described it as someone confirming that I was reliable. I knew the landlord wanted a guarantor. I avoided that word because I thought it would make her hesitate.

She hasn't signed anything. I've corrected what I told her and said she can decline. I've also read mygov.scot's guarantor guidance, which explains that the role can carry legal responsibility for costs if the tenant doesn't meet the agreement. It isn't a character reference.

She says the problem is that I tried to get the yes before explaining the request. She's right. I'm anxious about losing the flat, and I'm tempted to send her another message explaining how unlikely I think a problem would be.

Would any further reassurance help, or would it keep asking her to talk herself out of a risk I deliberately played down? I need another housing plan that doesn't depend on her forgiving me quickly.

Discussion

5 community replies

The Scottish Government guidance describes a financial and legal commitment, including potential unpaid rent and other costs. Your confidence that you'll pay doesn't turn the request into a reference. She needs the actual agreement and room for independent advice if she wants it, without a sales pitch from you.

“Just” did a lot of work in that conversation. You knew the accurate word could change her answer and substituted a smaller request. Naming that choice will matter more than producing a longer account of why you want the flat.

Tell the landlord accurately where the application stands rather than representing her agreement as pending paperwork. What alternatives are available is something to establish with them or an appropriate housing adviser; don't build your next promise around another person's assumed consent.

If she now says no, should you ask whether it's because of the money risk or because she no longer trusts you? I'm not sure that question would be fair while you're still hoping to rescue this application.

I'd leave that investigation alone for now. She can decline without sorting her reasons into categories that invite you to argue with them. You can repair the misleading request even if she never takes on the guarantor role.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions