Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I asked my son what he wanted for his birthday, then bought the interest I preferred

Confessions category photographConfessions

My son asked for a painting set. I bought him a science kit and said he'd find it more interesting.

He asked why I'd asked him to choose. I told him presents were about surprises, not orders. But I hadn't made a surprising choice within something he enjoyed. I wanted the sort of present that made me picture a particular future for him.

I can return the unopened kit and get the painting set. I don't want to make that sound like giving in to a child who demanded the right gift when he had answered a question I chose to ask.

How do I apologise without announcing that I think his actual interests are less impressive? I need to stop turning a birthday into a quiet attempt to steer him towards a version of himself I prefer.

Discussion

5 community replies

You don't need to tell him the whole imagined future to correct the choice. “I asked what you wanted, then dismissed your answer because I preferred something else. That wasn't fair” is an honest start.

A parent can introduce new interests without making a birthday request the opportunity to replace an existing one. The painting set and curiosity about science don't have to compete for permission to matter.

If you return the kit, describe that as correcting your decision, not rewarding a tantrum the story hasn't described. He asked why you hadn't used the information you requested.

There is still a difference between asking for ideas and promising a particular purchase. Children won't always receive exactly what they name. How do you preserve that without accepting the narrator's excuse here?

By being accurate about what was offered and why something else was chosen. A budget or unavailable item would be a different conversation. Here the narrator says the aim was to substitute a preferred interest, then used “surprise” to avoid admitting it. That is the specific choice to repair.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions