Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I asked my cousin to give me Grandma's brooch after quietly selling the bracelet she gave me

Confessions category photographConfessions

My cousin wore Grandma's brooch to dinner. I said it should really stay with the eldest granddaughter, meaning me. Grandma had given it to my cousin herself.

Grandma gave me a bracelet. I sold it when I needed money for a move. I don't think selling it made me a bad granddaughter, and I didn't expect to spend the rest of my life explaining that choice. But I left the sale out while telling my cousin how important it was to preserve family pieces.

She said she'd looked after the brooch for years and didn't understand why I was asking for it now. I nearly replied that it meant more to me. What I actually know is that seeing it made me miss Grandma, and I wanted something I could wear too.

I'm withdrawing the request. Do I also need to tell her about the bracelet? I don't want a trial about my finances, but I did use a principle I hadn't followed myself to make her gift sound like something she ought to surrender.

Discussion

5 community replies

Missing Grandma doesn't create a ranking in which your cousin's attachment counts less. The brooch was given to her. You can say seeing it stirred up feelings without asking her to solve those feelings by handing it over.

You don't have to condemn the bracelet sale to recognise the inconsistency. Needing money for a move and wanting a keepsake now can both be true. The unfair step was turning that wish into a rule about which granddaughter should have this particular piece.

“I shouldn't have claimed it belonged with me. Grandma chose to give it to you, and I'm sorry I put you in that position.” That withdraws the pressure without asking your cousin to agree that she'd have been generous if she'd accepted it.

I'm not sure the sale needs a detailed confession. You can correct your claim about preserving family pieces without giving the price, explaining the move or inviting an assessment of whether the need was serious enough.

The details can stay private. But if you're leaving her with the impression that you've preserved every gift while she's somehow failing the tradition, correct that impression too. “I sold the bracelet when I needed to, so I shouldn't have used that argument against you” is enough.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions