Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I ask my sister to be the bigger person because my brother is harder to challenge

Confessions category photographConfessions

My brother interrupted my sister's story twice, then called it boring when she asked to finish. I caught her in the kitchen and asked her to let it go.

I said I wanted a peaceful dinner. What I meant was that asking him to stop would probably lead to a louder argument. She was the person likely to listen to me, so she became the person I asked to change.

This isn't the first time. I've praised her for being mature when what I appreciated was her willingness to absorb something unpleasant without making the evening harder for me.

She told me, "You only need me to be bigger because you won't speak to him."

How do I respond to that? I don't think I can make my brother behave well, but I can see how I've been turning that limit into a duty for my sister to keep accepting the same treatment.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell her she identified the pattern correctly: you approached the person most likely to cooperate, even though she hadn't caused this exchange. Apologise for asking her to absorb it. Don't attach a new request that she now help you find the perfect way to challenge him.

You can't guarantee your brother will respond well, but you can stop endorsing his behaviour through demands on her. At the next interruption, a brief "She was still speaking" would state your own position. It doesn't require her to organise or reward your intervention.

Your sister may choose to challenge him, leave the conversation or leave dinner. You don't have to promise those choices will keep everyone cheerful. If your priority remains an undisturbed meal at any cost, you'll be tempted to recruit the most accommodating person again.

There is also a conversation you can have with your brother away from the table: describe the interruption and the insult you heard. Keep it as your concern. Saying your sister has demanded that you speak to him would send the responsibility straight back to her.

Keeping it as your concern matters even if she welcomes the conversation. "I didn't like how you spoke to her" owns your judgment; "She's upset again" casts her as the problem. You can report what you witnessed without making her feelings a case he has to agree is valid.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions