Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I answer for my quiet friend because I think I'm helping

Confessions category photographConfessions

Someone asked my friend about her trip. She paused, and I answered with the story she'd told me earlier. She said, 'I'd like to tell it myself.'

I often fill the space when she's meeting new people. I know she can find a busy group tiring, and I assume speaking for her saves an awkward moment. I haven't asked whether that is the help she wants. Sometimes I even explain that she's quiet while she's sitting beside me, which gives her another description to work around before she can speak.

How do I apologise without abruptly refusing to help if she does want support? I don't want to replace one assumption with a rule that leaves no room for what she actually asks. I need to stop treating a pause as a request made to me.

Discussion

5 community replies

Apologise for taking the answer before she had chosen whether to give it. You can say you assumed help was wanted and should have asked. The pause didn't supply the agreement you were acting on.

Let her describe what, if anything, helps in those groups. She might prefer time, a question directed back to her, or an agreed way to ask you to step in. Don't prepare the whole support arrangement before hearing her answer.

Stop introducing her through the label of being quiet unless she wants that. Your explanation may be well intended, but it speaks about her in the same moment you're already speaking for her.

You can remain available without filling every silence. If she has asked for a particular kind of help, follow that request; if not, let the person who received the question decide how to answer it.

Availability doesn't need a public demonstration that you've learned to stand back. Give her the space without announcing the new rule to the room. The conversation can return to her trip instead of becoming another account of how you manage her participation.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions