Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Confessions · Advice & Questions ·

I admitted breaking a lamp while house-sitting but hid the gathering that broke it

Confessions category photographConfessions

I told my brother I'd knocked his lamp over while cleaning. A friend knocked it over during a gathering I'd promised not to host.

He'd asked me to stay in his flat while he was away and said no visitors. I agreed, then invited six friends because I thought one quiet evening wouldn't matter. The friend who caught the lamp didn't know about that agreement.

My brother has accepted that I'll cover a replacement. I'm tempted to treat that as the whole repair: the lamp is the only damage I know about, and telling him the rest will make the apology much harder.

What do I owe him about the evening itself? I don't want to present the guests as the problem or make my willingness to pay a reason he should be satisfied with the version I've already given.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell him there was a gathering and that you had agreed not to have visitors. Correct the cleaning story explicitly. Otherwise he has accepted your offer about the lamp on an account of the evening that you know is incomplete.

His concern may extend beyond the object that broke. Let him ask about who was there and how his home was used. "Only damage I know about" is something you can say accurately; "nothing else mattered" isn't something you can decide for him.

Don't describe your friend as the cause of the whole situation. They can take responsibility for knocking the lamp while you take responsibility for inviting people against the agreement. One person's accident doesn't explain away another person's choice.

What if your friend offers to contribute towards the replacement? That's something you can discuss, but don't use it to finish the lamp transaction before correcting the account to your brother. The gathering doesn't become less relevant because someone else can help pay.

And don't ask the guests to coordinate a milder version for him. You can answer what you remember and say when you're unsure. Getting everyone to call it a brief drop-in would add a new layer of concealment to the one you are trying to end.

Join the discussion

More in Confessions