Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

HR wants to turn our informal lunch book swap into an engagement programme

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

I started a voluntary book swap at lunch. A few colleagues bring something they have finished, and people drift in when they feel like it. The company lets us use a spare meeting room, but I have not been running it on HR’s behalf.

HR now wants to feature it as a staff engagement programme, collect a member list and set an attendance target. My manager thinks this is a nice recognition of my initiative. I’m worried it will change the feeling of the group and make me responsible for recruiting people who only wanted to swap a book occasionally.

I haven’t asked the others what they think, so I don’t want to claim they all oppose it. How would you respond to HR while recognising the support we receive and leaving room for participants to choose what happens next?

Discussion

5 community replies

Separate the offer of support from the proposed duties. Ask what HR wants from an organiser, what information it wants and why attendance needs a target. You can appreciate the room and publicity without accepting an ongoing recruitment or reporting role that has not been discussed.

Say what you are willing to keep doing: arranging a time, inviting people to bring books and leaving participation optional, for example. Then identify anything you cannot take on. A clear limit on your role is more useful than promising to keep the group informal while quietly accepting every new task.

Ask the participants before describing the group as enthusiastic or resistant. Explain the actual proposal, including publicity and attendance tracking, and give people an easy way to respond privately. Someone may welcome official support while disliking a member list; a single yes-or-no vote could miss that distinction.

HR might bring useful resources and help people discover a group they would enjoy. It need not be a takeover. If the organiser rejects the programme immediately, the group could lose a chance to become more welcoming beyond the colleagues who already know one another.

That is a good reason to explore the offer. Suggest an open invitation and practical support without an attendance target as a starting point. Discuss with participants what information they are comfortable sharing, rather than handing over a list on their behalf. If HR needs a formal programme with different duties, ask who would run that version and whether people could still choose the informal swap.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work