Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

HR says my confidentiality clause stops me raising a safety concern outside the company

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

I raised a concern internally about records for workplace safety checks. Some entries appeared to have been completed before the checks happened. I have described what I saw, but I do not know the full explanation and am not claiming that every record is false.

HR reminded me that my contract contains a confidentiality clause and said I must not discuss company matters with an outside body. I’m an employee in England. GOV.UK says a clause cannot prevent a protected whistleblowing disclosure, but I also understand that protection is not a label I can attach to any disclosure I choose.

I want the concern assessed through an appropriate route, not posted online. How do I work out whom to approach and what to share without letting the clause end the discussion or assuming it gives me blanket immunity?

Discussion

5 community replies

Keep observation and inference separate: which entry you saw, when you saw it and why you thought the timing did not fit. “I saw this discrepancy and want it checked” is a stronger starting point than an accusation about everyone’s motives. If a current safety risk needs attention, use the relevant urgent safety route as well.

Could HR be trying to protect a confidential investigation rather than stop the concern? The employee could ask who is reviewing it and when an update is expected. An internal review may be real even if it cannot disclose every interview or finding.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work