Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

How should I handle judging a neighbour's window display when I helped make it?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

I recognised the paper stars before I saw the entry number. I had cut half of them at my neighbour's kitchen table.

I had offered to help with her window display before being asked to judge the street's decorating contest. I then accepted the judging role without mentioning it. There are two judges and a small bookshop voucher for the winner.

The organiser says everyone knows somebody, and the entries will be numbered. That won't stop me recognising this one. I haven't submitted any scores, and the entries aren't closed yet.

I would like to help judge, but I don't want my neighbour's display to carry a quiet advantage or become the one I mark harshly to prove I am fair.

Should I ask someone else to assess her entry, explain the connection to everyone, or step out of judging entirely? I want to correct the omission before the results make it look as though I only noticed the issue because of who won.

Discussion

5 community replies

Tell the organiser exactly what the connection is: you helped make part of the entry. “I know the entrant” understates the point you are worried about.

Numbering may help with some entries, but you already know this one. Don't agree that removing the name resolves your particular situation.

Make sure the entrant isn't quietly penalised for your omission. She made her display before you accepted the role, so a new condition imposed only on her could feel like she is paying for the judging arrangement.

Could the other judge assess that display alone, with the approach agreed before scoring? That seems less disruptive than losing a willing volunteer from the whole contest.

It may be workable, but agree how its score will be compared with entries assessed by both judges. The solution should be clear in advance, rather than improvised after the totals are known.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours