Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Relationships · Advice & Questions ·

How honest should I be when a friend asks whether I like the painting she's already bought?

Relationships category photographRelationships

My friend showed me a painting she'd just bought for her living room and said, "Be honest. Do you love it?" I don't. I can see why the colours appeal to her, but it isn't something I would choose.

I paused and she asked whether that meant I'd been politely approving things in her home for years. I hadn't expected a question about a painting to become a test of whether my compliments could be trusted. I don't want to invent enthusiasm, and I don't want to make a purchase she enjoys feel spoiled by my taste.

What is an honest answer that keeps this in proportion? She isn't asking me to choose between two things before buying. The painting is already on the wall, and I would rather understand what she loves about it than have my verdict become the main event.

Discussion

5 community replies

You can answer the question about your taste without announcing a verdict on the purchase: "It isn't the style I'd choose, but I can see the colours you liked." Only name a detail you actually appreciate.

Ask what she loves about it and give the answer real attention. That shouldn't be a manoeuvre to avoid admitting your preference. It can follow the honest answer and return the conversation to the painting she chose to live with.

Don't respond to one pause by withdrawing every past compliment. If those were sincere, say so. Liking different things doesn't require either a complete history of false approval or a new inventory of everything you dislike.

If she asks whether you think she made a mistake, separate that from whether you would buy it. You aren't the person whose room and daily enjoyment it needs to suit. Your different preference doesn't establish that her choice failed.

And you don't need to insist that she stop feeling disappointed by your answer. She may have hoped you would share her enthusiasm. You can let that small difference exist without upgrading it into a test of honesty across the whole friendship.

Join the discussion

More in Relationships