Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

How do we time a meeting chair's arguments without timing every bit of chairing?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

Our informal residents' meeting uses a timer so each person gets a brief turn on suggestions. I stop when mine goes off. The chair takes a turn for his own proposal, then adds several more points while responding to other people.

When I asked about that, he said he needs time to chair the discussion. I agree that calling speakers, explaining the agenda and summarising takes time. Some of the extra comments, though, are new arguments for his proposal rather than instructions about running the meeting.

How can I ask for a fair distinction without insisting that every administrative sentence counts against his speaking time? We have limited meeting time, and I don't want a prolonged dispute about the timer to crowd out everyone's actual suggestions. There are no formal standing orders; this is an arrangement we made to help the conversation.

Discussion

5 community replies

Bring an example of the distinction you want: calling the next speaker is chairing; adding another reason to support his own plan is a contribution to the debate. A clear example may work better than accusing him of always talking too much.

The chair does have extra work, so identical total speaking time wouldn't necessarily be fair. Focus on comparable time for advocating a proposal, while allowing the administrative work needed to keep the meeting moving.

Agree the approach before the next discussion, including who keeps time and what they should flag. Otherwise the timekeeper has to invent a judgment in the middle of a disagreement with the person running the room.

Could someone else chair the part of the agenda where his own proposal is discussed? That might let him argue for it in the same way as other residents while another person manages turns.

That could help if someone is willing and the handover is clear. It doesn't require replacing him for the whole meeting. A short, agreed change of role may be easier to use than debating whether every comment he makes is administration or advocacy.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours