Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Relationships · Advice & Questions ·

How do we talk about marriage when my partner calls it "just a piece of paper"?

Relationships category photographRelationships

I said I could imagine us getting married. My partner smiled and said, "We're already committed. Why do we need a piece of paper?" I went quiet because it sounded as if the thing I wanted was a shallow extra.

We've lived together happily for several years. I'm drawn to making promises in front of the people close to us. She doesn't like the idea of a big wedding and says what we do every day matters more than an event. I agree about the daily life. I still want to understand whether she's rejecting a large celebration or marriage itself.

How do I reopen this without trying to prove that one of us understands commitment better? I want to explain what the idea means to me and hear her actual answer, rather than let a phrase finish a conversation we haven't really had.

Discussion

5 community replies

Start with what you value about making the promises publicly. That gives her something more specific than a wish for a document or a party. You don't need to dismiss the commitment you already have to say you would welcome another way of expressing it.

You have identified an unanswered question: a large wedding and marriage itself may be different subjects for her. Ask which she means. Don't plan a smaller ceremony as a solution until you know whether the size of the event is actually the difficulty.

Tell her how the phrase landed without insisting she meant to belittle you. She may have been describing her own priorities and missed that it closed yours down. "I felt something important to me had been made to sound trivial" would open that part honestly.

Once you both understand the meanings, leave room for a real difference in what you want. The conversation shouldn't become an exercise in discovering the correct definition of commitment that makes one person's preference disappear.

That may be harder than settling the wording. If she genuinely doesn't want marriage and you do, you would need to consider that difference directly. Neither a large wedding nor a tiny one should be offered as an easy compromise before the underlying wish is clear.

Join the discussion

More in Relationships