Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Funny · Advice & Questions ·

How do we stop a pretend film argument sounding real to a new friend?

Funny category photographFunny

'I don't know whether I should leave you two to it,' our new friend said.

My oldest friend and I were pretending to fall out because I dislike a film he loves. It's an old routine: exaggerated disbelief, a demand that I return my friendship privileges and a ridiculous defence of the film.

We were both enjoying it. Our guest hadn't seen the routine before. She offered to change the subject, which made me realise that our private tone hadn't come with an explanation.

Can I simply say we're joking, or should we change how we do this around people who don't know us yet? I want the new friendship to include more than watching an apparently serious dispute about a film she hasn't seen.

Discussion

5 community replies

Explain briefly and then change the subject: 'That's an old pretend argument between us; sorry, we didn't give you the context.' The explanation works better when the guest also gets a chance to join a different conversation.

Don't ask her to prove she understands by enjoying another round. She has already signalled uncertainty. You and your friend can keep the routine for a setting where everybody actually wants it.

Talk with your friend afterwards about noticing newcomers sooner. You don't need to decide that the old joke was always bad. This occasion showed that a shared history can leave someone else outside the conversation.

Saying we're joking clarifies your intention, but it doesn't automatically make the performance enjoyable for the person watching. Give her room to prefer another topic without calling her too serious.

Treat the explanation as a transition rather than permission to restart. The film can survive an evening without its familiar trial, and your new friend can meet the two people underneath the argument.

Join the discussion

More in Funny