Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

How do I write a fair review of paid work done by a neighbour?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

I typed “She ruined my curtains and didn't care,” then stopped before posting it.

I paid a neighbour to shorten two curtain panels. She returned them later than agreed, and they are visibly different lengths when laid flat together. I asked her to correct them. She offered a slot in three weeks and said I was making a fuss over something small.

I am annoyed about the work and her response. I don't actually know whether the curtains are ruined, and “didn't care” describes what I took from her message rather than something I can establish.

She has also asked me not to leave a poor review because we live near each other. I don't want a public argument at the gate, but I don't think paying a neighbour means I must supply only praise.

What would be a fair account of the experience? I am still deciding whether to accept the correction date, and I want to keep that discussion separate from threatening a review to get a quicker appointment.

Discussion

5 community replies

Describe the agreed work, the late return, the different lengths and the correction offered. Those details tell a future customer more than a conclusion about her character.

If you review before the offered correction happens, say that it has been offered and is still unresolved. Don't write as though she refused all further work when that isn't what happened.

Keep her home details and the residents' disagreement out of the review. Focus on the paid service rather than recruiting the street to decide which neighbour is being reasonable.

Would it be better to wait until you have decided about the correction? You might then be able to describe the whole job rather than an argument still in progress.

Waiting could make the account more complete if you are willing to do so. You can choose that without promising never to review, and without suggesting that only a faster appointment will keep the review from appearing.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours