Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Relationships · Advice & Questions ·

How do I talk about a difficult part of childhood when my brother remembers it happily?

Relationships category photographRelationships

We found one of Dad's old homework notebooks. My brother laughed at the red corrections and said, "He put so much time into us." I said I remembered dreading those sessions. He replied, "That's unfair. We had a good childhood."

We agree that the sessions happened. We seem to remember what they felt like very differently. My brother felt helped; I felt as if I could never finish a page well enough. I don't want him to give up his good memory or join me in declaring Dad a bad parent.

I would like to describe my own experience without having the conversation turn into a vote on the whole family. How do I say that? I also want to make room for his version, rather than demanding the kind of agreement I'm upset not to receive.

Discussion

5 community replies

Stay with the specific experience instead of asking either memory to classify the whole childhood. "I'm not arguing that you felt supported. I remember feeling under pressure during those sessions" lets you describe the same event without requiring the same meaning.

You can ask him not to answer your feeling with a verdict about whether the family was good. That larger question wasn't the one you raised. He might find it easier to listen if you also make clear that you aren't asking him to condemn Dad.

If there are factual details you aren't certain about, say so. Being careful about those doesn't require withdrawing the feeling you do remember. You can distinguish what happened, what you recall and what it meant to you without treating them as one indivisible claim.

Ask what he feels he would be agreeing to by listening. He may hear your account as a request to reject something he values. You may hear his affection as a request to stop describing something that was difficult. Naming that mismatch could make the conversation less defensive.

A useful response from either of you could be, "I didn't experience it that way, but I want to understand what it was like for you." That leaves both accounts in the room. You don't need to arrive at a single family-approved feeling before the conversation can be worthwhile.

Join the discussion

More in Relationships