Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

How do I support a neighbour's memorial without reading a statement I don't believe?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

My neighbour sent me the closing reading for her husband's memorial and said, “It would mean a lot if you read this.”

She wrote it herself. It includes a first-person statement about what the speaker believes happens after death. I don't share that belief. I would like to attend and support her, and I would be comfortable reading a memory of him or another passage we agree on.

I haven't accepted the reading role. I worry that declining this text will sound like using a painful occasion to announce my own views. I also don't want to agree now and change the words in front of everyone.

How can I offer another contribution quietly, while leaving the family in control of the service? I want to be honest about what I can say without turning her invitation into a debate about belief.

Discussion

5 community replies

Speak privately and early: you would be honoured to contribute, but aren't comfortable speaking that particular affirmation in the first person. Offer the kind of reading you could give.

Keep the explanation short. You don't need to argue against her belief or tell her how the text ought to comfort other people.

Let her decide whether an alternative fits the service. Offering a memory isn't permission to replace the chosen reading yourself on the day.

Some people would understand a reading as sharing the family's chosen words rather than declaring the reader's own belief. Could that distinction make it comfortable for you?

It might for some readers, but you can decide it doesn't for you. Explain that personal limit without insisting her text is wrong, then leave room for another reader or an agreed different contribution.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours