Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

How do I share an anonymous complaint when its details identify the writer?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

The note began, “I was selling blue bowls beside the entrance when my prices were criticised in front of customers.”

Only one resident sold blue bowls at our craft fair. We had invited anonymous feedback, saying we would summarise it at the planning meeting. The committee now wants to read every note aloud so nobody can accuse us of leaving things out.

The complaint describes remarks by another volunteer and asks us to discuss how stallholders are treated. I think that deserves attention. Reading the whole account would also make it fairly clear who wrote it, even without a name.

I don't want to contact the person I suspect and effectively announce that I have identified her. I also don't want to turn a specific complaint into “everyone should be nice” and lose the reason it was submitted.

How can I give the committee enough information to address the issue while honouring what we promised about the feedback? Nothing from the box has been shared yet.

Discussion

5 community replies

Return to the promise you made: a summary at the meeting. Verbatim reading is a new proposal, and you have a concrete reason it may expose the writer.

You can report the concern about volunteers criticising stallholders' prices in front of customers without describing the bowls or stall position. Include the requested change, rather than reducing it to a general appeal for kindness.

Don't ask the suspected writer to confirm herself just so you can say you sought permission. You may be wrong, and your process shouldn't require people to identify themselves after submitting anonymously.

The volunteer whose remarks are described may need a chance to respond. How can that happen if every specific detail is removed?

That may require a separate, carefully handled conversation rather than reading an accusation to the whole meeting. First agree what the committee can investigate from the information it has and what it can change generally; don't promise a finding the anonymous process can't support.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours