Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Relationships · Advice & Questions ·

How do I respond when a friend argues with every compliment I give her?

Relationships category photographRelationships

I told my friend I liked the picture she'd painted. She pointed out three things wrong with it and said I was only being kind. I explained what I liked. Ten minutes later, I was still trying to prove that I'd meant the first sentence.

This happens with small compliments too. I don't need her to agree that everything is wonderful. I would like a positive remark to be something I can offer without immediately defending my judgement or honesty.

Should I stop trying to persuade her and let the compliment stand, or ask what kind of response she actually wants when she shows me something? I care about her. I don't want every bit of encouragement to become a debate neither of us seems able to finish.

Discussion

5 community replies

You can leave the compliment as your own opinion: "You don't have to like the same parts I do; I meant what I said." Then stop building a case. Her uncertainty about the picture doesn't require you to produce a verdict she can no longer contest.

Ask whether she was hoping for appreciation, discussion or criticism when she showed you the work. She may be using the exchange to talk through what she dislikes while you think she is asking you to establish that it's good.

Be careful not to make accepting compliments another performance she must get right for you. You can say the repeated claim that you're merely being kind feels dismissive of your honesty, without requiring an enthusiastic thank-you every time.

If the conversation loops, gently change its purpose. "I'm not going to argue you into liking it, but I'd enjoy hearing what you were trying to make" moves towards curiosity rather than another round of reassurance.

And if you don't want a longer discussion just then, you can stop there too. A sincere compliment isn't a promise to keep talking until she feels differently. You can remain interested in her work without being responsible for arriving at a shared opinion of every piece.

Join the discussion

More in Relationships