Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

How do I respect a neighbour's Tooth Fairy story without asking my child to say he lied?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

My eight-year-old told the six-year-old next door that parents leave the money. The younger child hadn't asked, and was upset.

At our house we treat the Tooth Fairy as a story. I hadn't prepared my son for other families doing it differently. I am willing to apologise for the uninvited announcement and explain why he shouldn't spoil another child's fun.

The neighbour now wants him to say he made it up and that the fairy is definitely real. He doesn't want to say something he doesn't believe.

How do I take responsibility for the awkward moment without making the children repair it through another claim about what is true? I would like the adults to agree on a kind way to handle future questions, rather than have the children argue over whose family is right.

Discussion

5 community replies

Apologise for the uninvited announcement and help your son understand that another family's story isn't his to interrupt. That is a concrete behaviour to address without requiring him to adopt the same account.

Speak with the parent yourself rather than sending your son over with a line he has been told to perform. The adults can handle their different approaches without another doorstep debate between the children.

Don't promise that a particular apology will restore the younger child's belief. You can offer care for the upset without guaranteeing an outcome neither adult can control.

A future answer such as “We do it differently at our house—ask your grown-up” might be gentler than explaining the whole difference to the younger child.

That could work as a truthful response to a future question. It needn't be followed by another explanation or a demand that either child announce the other family's story is wrong.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours