Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

How do I repair over-detailed feedback on a neighbour's welcome speech?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

A neighbour asked me to read her short welcome speech and be honest about it. I returned the page covered in suggestions, including changes to the greeting, the order and most of the jokes.

She said she had wanted to know whether it sounded welcoming, not have it rewritten in my voice. Looking back, I treated several personal preferences as corrections. I hadn't asked what kind of feedback she wanted.

Some suggestions still seem useful to me, but sending another explanation of every edit would probably repeat the mistake. How can I apologise for the way I handled it without pretending that honest feedback must mean saying everything is perfect?

Discussion

5 community replies

Start by acknowledging the mismatch: she wanted a response to how it came across, and you supplied a rewrite. Ask whether she wants any further feedback before sending more of it.

A page covered in changes can make the original voice seem unwelcome. You don't have to agree every sentence was ideal to recognise why the overall effect hurt.

Separate optional wording preferences from anything she actually needs checked. If she invites another pass, a few prioritised comments may be more useful than presenting every possible alteration.

She did ask you to be honest. I wouldn't turn this into a promise that you will only praise her work in future.

Agreed. The apology can be for taking over the voice and failing to clarify the request. You can still give an honest answer when asked, with a clearer understanding of what help is wanted.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours