Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

How do I refuse a neighbour's investment pitch without accusing him of running a scam?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

A neighbour in the UK keeps sending me details of an investment scheme he has joined. He describes the returns as guaranteed and says he would hate me to miss out. I haven't paid anything or given the scheme my personal information.

When I said I didn't understand how it made money, he offered to introduce me to the person who signed him up. He took my hesitation personally: 'Do you really think I'd send you something dodgy?'

I don't know whether he has checked it properly, and I don't know enough to label it a scam. The FCA's guidance on avoiding scams warns about tempting investment returns and pressure to act quickly, which is enough to make me stop and check rather than rely on a neighbour's confidence.

I want to decline without turning this into an argument about his honesty. Should I explain my concerns once, or would that simply invite him to keep trying to answer them?

Discussion

5 community replies

You can decline without establishing that it is fraudulent. 'I'm not investing, and I don't want an introduction' answers the offer. His confidence in it doesn't create an obligation for you to investigate until you find a reason he accepts.

If you explain, keep the concern about the proposal: you don't understand the source of the returns and won't put money into it. Avoid saying he must be dishonest or foolish. He may sincerely believe what he is passing on.

Use the FCA's own route for checks rather than contact details supplied by the scheme. Its guidance explains checking the firm and matching its details through the FCA Firm Checker. That is a checking step, not a promise that a particular investment is safe.

I would send the FCA guidance once because he has already joined. He might dismiss it, but a private message gives him a way to reconsider without having to defend his decision in front of the street.

Offering it once is reasonable; making yourself responsible for persuading him could pull you into endless debate. You can say why you are declining, share the guidance, and ask him to stop sending pitches. Don't claim you have uncovered fraud when you haven't.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours