Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Funny · Advice & Questions ·

How do I give a simple preference without adding so many disclaimers that it disappears?

Funny category photographFunny

My friend showed me two birthday-card designs she had made and asked which I liked. One had a crab in a tie. I liked the crab.

What I said was, 'Probably that one, but that's just me, and maybe the other one is more birthday-ish, and I don't know whether everyone likes crabs.'

She asked, 'So which one?' I had managed to make a personal preference sound like an unresolved survey.

I don't know the recipient well, and I can't promise my choice would be theirs. My friend wasn't asking for a prediction; she was asking what I thought.

How do I give an honest opinion without either burying it under caveats or sounding as though I have been appointed the final authority on formalwear for shellfish?

Discussion

5 community replies

'I prefer the crab; the tie makes me laugh' is a complete answer to the question she asked. It identifies your choice and gives her something useful about why you chose it. She can weigh that alongside her own view.

You only need to mark the uncertainty that matters. 'I don't know the recipient's taste, but my favourite is the crab' covers that limit without retreating from the preference. You don't have to list every possible person who might dislike it.

If she wants help choosing for the recipient, ask what that person tends to enjoy. That's a different question from which design you like. You can contribute your reaction without pretending you know the recipient better than she does.

Make room for her to choose the other design after hearing you. Sometimes we hedge because we feel a clear opinion will become an instruction. If you can accept her picking differently, your preference doesn't need so much protective wrapping.

Exactly. She can use your reason and still choose the other card. You don't need to weaken 'I like the crab' in advance to prove you will tolerate that outcome; you can simply be pleasant about whichever one she sends.

Join the discussion

More in Funny