Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

How do I decline witnessing a neighbour's will when it leaves me a gift?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

My neighbour pointed to a gift for me in her will, then handed me the witness pen.

We live in England. She had asked whether I could come round to sign something and showed me the paragraph when I arrived. I hadn't known I was named in it. I have not signed.

The government's guidance on making a will says witnesses and their married partners cannot receive gifts under it. I said we should pause and check the arrangements. She replied that it was only a signature and that refusing made her thoughtful gift sound like a problem.

I appreciate the intention. I don't want to improvise a legal fix at her kitchen table, or pronounce on the rest of a document I haven't reviewed.

How do I make the refusal clear while helping her find an appropriate next step? I would rather she had suitable independent witnesses and advice than either of us signed to avoid an awkward moment.

Discussion

5 community replies

Thank her for thinking of you, then separate the two decisions: you appreciate the gift and won't witness this document. Appreciation doesn't require using the pen she has handed you.

Suggest contacting whoever prepared the will or an appropriate legal adviser about the signing arrangements. You can help her make that enquiry without offering your own correction to the document.

Keep the point narrow. The government guidance addresses gifts to witnesses; it doesn't give you a basis to declare her whole will invalid or reassure her that everything else is fine.

Could you simply decline the gift and then witness? That might seem easier than finding another person if you don't want the money anyway.

Don't assume a spoken refusal changes the document or resolves the witnessing issue. Get appropriate advice before changing the arrangement; finding suitable independent witnesses avoids asking you to invent that fix.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours