Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

How do I decline a neighbours' mushroom tasting based only on an app result?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

My neighbour held up his phone and said, “It identified them. We'll cook some after the walk.”

He has planned a small foraging outing near our US homes. The tasting would use wild mushrooms he found locally. The app result is the only identification he has obtained; no mushroom expert has confirmed them. Nobody has eaten any.

Poison Control advises against eating wild mushrooms without expert identification. I am not qualified to identify them either, and I don't want to turn a group discussion of pictures into a safety decision.

I would enjoy a walk that leaves the mushrooms uneaten. He thinks declining the tasting means I don't trust him to organise an ordinary afternoon.

How do I ask for that part of the plan to change while keeping the invitation to spend time together? I want the missing identification addressed before anyone is offered a portion.

Discussion

5 community replies

Separate the walk from eating the finds. You can enjoy looking at what grows locally without accepting the app result as the basis for a tasting.

Give the organiser the source and identify the gap: no expert has confirmed these mushrooms. Don't offer your own visual identification as the competing answer.

Make sure the change reaches anyone expecting food at the end. Quietly refusing your own portion wouldn't correct the group's understanding of what has been checked.

He plans to cook them first. Would that address the concern even if the identification is uncertain?

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours