Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

How do I correct shared compost instructions after I told neighbours to add compostable pet-waste bags?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

I wrote “Anything compostable can go in” on the sign beside our shared backyard heap.

A neighbour followed it and added filled dog-waste bags labelled compostable. I had meant fruit scraps, leaves and similar garden material, but the sign didn't say that. The heap is intended for our vegetable beds.

We live in the US. The EPA's home-composting guidance lists pet waste among materials to avoid, and explains that compostable bags generally aren't suitable for backyard piles. I have stopped adding material while we seek appropriate local advice about the heap.

I don't want to blame the neighbour who followed my instruction. I also don't want to quietly replace the sign and let someone spread the existing material without knowing why we paused.

What should the correction say, and how do I keep it useful without claiming I know how to put the heap right? I am happy to contact our local extension service; I don't have a tested remedy to offer.

Discussion

5 community replies

Say that your instruction was too broad and explain the pause. You don't need to identify the household that followed it in order to tell everyone why the old sign should no longer be used.

Use a specific accepted-materials list when the project resumes, checked against the guidance for your actual system. “Compostable” on a product isn't the same instruction as “put it in this backyard heap.”

Tell the adviser what was added and how the compost was intended to be used. Ask contributors for relevant details privately, without turning that request into a search for somebody to blame.

Would a public correction frighten everyone away from composting? It might be tempting to deal with the heap quietly and just replace the sign.

People need to know not to use the paused material. You can give that clear instruction without claiming anyone has been harmed or that the whole project must end. Explain that you are seeking advice, then share the actual next step when it is established.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours