Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

How do I change a neighbour's party playlist after telling her to choose whatever she liked?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

I asked a neighbour to choose music for a supper at my house and said, 'Whatever you think will work.' I meant music in the background while people ate and talked, but I didn't actually explain that.

She has now sent a carefully arranged mix intended for dancing. When I said I had imagined a quieter meal, she replied that I had given her a free hand and she had spent ages putting it together. I can see why asking for a different atmosphere now feels like changing the brief after the work is done.

The supper hasn't happened. How can I take responsibility for the vague request and change the music plan without expecting her to start again for me? I value the effort, but I don't want to run a different kind of evening simply to demonstrate that appreciation.

Discussion

5 community replies

Own the missing brief directly. You asked her to choose freely without describing the meal you had in mind. That doesn't mean the supper has to become a dance party, but it does mean the change shouldn't be presented as her failure.

Describe the atmosphere you want without insulting her choices. 'We need to be able to talk over dinner' is more useful than calling the mix inappropriate or saying nobody will like it.

Offer to take over the music selection rather than ask her for another carefully planned mix. She can decide whether she wants to adapt anything herself, but you shouldn't assume the extra work is included.

Would a short dancing session after supper use part of what she prepared? It could be a way to include her idea while keeping the meal as you intended.

That could work if you actually want that part of the evening. Don't promise it merely to avoid acknowledging the changed brief. Appreciation for her work and a clear decision about the supper can be enough, even if the mix waits for another occasion.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours