Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

How do I challenge a public 'unreliable' label on our neighbour-help list?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

The organiser put “unreliable” beside my name on the list of neighbours offering occasional errands.

I had cancelled a shopping collection after my work shift changed. I told the recipient the day before, and she arranged another way to get it. I accept that changing an offer can create work for someone else.

We hadn't agreed to public performance labels. The organiser says people need to know whom they can count on. I agree that accepted tasks need clear arrangements; I don't think one label explains what happened or what I can offer now.

How do I ask for it to be removed without sounding as though volunteers should never receive feedback? I still want to help occasionally, but I don't want joining the list to mean accepting an ongoing public assessment of my character.

Discussion

5 community replies

Acknowledge the cancellation, then question the label and process separately. You can accept responsibility for changing an offer without agreeing that “unreliable” is a useful standing description.

Propose recording actual availability and whether a particular task has been accepted. Those facts would help a recipient plan more directly than a broad judgement beside a name.

Discuss feedback with the organiser privately first. Ask how concerns are raised, checked and addressed, rather than demanding that nobody ever describe a problem with a favour.

Recipients may be depending on help and need confidence that somebody will turn up. Removing every adverse comment could leave them with less information.

That concern deserves a process, including clear confirmations and backup arrangements. It doesn't require an unagreed public character label; specific, checked concerns can be handled without pretending every volunteer is always available.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours