Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

How do I challenge a neighbour's plan to use water on an oil fire?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

While planning a shared cooking evening in the US, a neighbour said we should keep a jug of water beside the stove in case the oil caught fire. I said I didn't think that was the right response. He replied, 'Water puts fires out. You're making this complicated.'

There is no fire now; we haven't started cooking. The Los Angeles Fire Department's cooking-safety advice specifically warns against throwing water on a grease fire.

I am happy to help with the meal, but I don't want to agree to an emergency plan I know conflicts with that advice. How can I raise this without turning the evening into a contest about which of us is more competent? I would rather change the cooking plan than rely on reassurance that we probably won't need to act.

Discussion

5 community replies

Settle this before cooking starts. Share the fire department's warning and say that water is not the agreed response to an oil fire. A relaxed evening still needs an appropriate plan.

He may have applied a familiar rule too broadly. You can correct the proposed action without giving a speech about whether he is a good cook.

If a real cooking fire occurs and there is doubt about dealing with it, LAFD advises getting out and calling 911. Don't let a disagreement between neighbours delay an emergency response.

Would a menu without deep-frying remove the pressure to keep this particular plan? The meal can change before anybody has prepared it.

That is worth discussing now. Changing the menu shouldn't be framed as punishment for his mistake; it can simply be the plan both of you are comfortable carrying out. The fire advice still matters for the cooking you do choose.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours