Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

How do I challenge a neighbour's plan for children to skate on a frozen pond?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

“If we get a proper freeze, we'll let them skate on the pond,” my neighbour told the children while discussing a winter gathering.

He means the open pond behind our homes, not a managed ice rink. This is a plan for a future cold spell. He says he will look at the ice first and only proceed if it seems solid.

I said my child wouldn't be going onto it and asked him to remove that activity from the invitation. The Royal Life Saving Society UK's winter guidance advises staying off ice on open water, even after prolonged cold. I don't want a reassuring description to replace that advice.

He thinks I am spoiling the anticipation before the weather has even happened. I would happily help with a gathering that stays on land, but I want the pond plan addressed now, before the children arrive expecting it.

How do I make that distinction clear to the organiser and other parents without turning this into an argument about how brave we were as children?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask for the invitation to be corrected explicitly. Quietly deciding that your child won't go leaves the same activity promised to everyone else.

Focus on the proposed place and the current guidance. Stories about what adults did years ago won't establish whether the planned activity should happen now.

Offer help with the gathering you are willing to support, while being clear that your participation doesn't endorse the pond activity. The winter occasion can still exist without that promise.

What if he tests the ice himself before allowing any children onto it? He may feel that would answer the concern about judging by appearance.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours