Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Funny · Advice & Questions ·

How do I ask for no hints about a novel, even ones described as spoiler-free?

Funny category photographFunny

'No spoilers, but pay attention to the gardener,' my friend said.

I'm reading a novel she recommended. I had told her I was enjoying it. Now she keeps offering clues about which scenes matter and saying I will understand a particular character later.

She hasn't told me an ending. I also can't meet the gardener on the page without mentally putting a large arrow over his head. When I asked for no spoilers, she said these weren't spoilers, just encouragement.

How do I make the request clearer without arguing about the definition? I'd like to share my enjoyment with her and still discover for myself which people deserve an imaginary arrow.

Discussion

5 community replies

Specify the boundary you want: 'Please don't tell me which details or characters will matter later.' That is easier to follow than asking you both to agree on a single definition of spoiler.

Offer a way to discuss it that works for you. You might talk about what you've already read and ask her to save reactions to later events until you've finished.

She may think she's helping you notice the best parts. Explain the effect on your reading rather than questioning that intention: you now anticipate a reveal whenever the gardener appears.

Let her know whether you'd like any commentary at all while you're reading. A recommendation can feel like the start of an ongoing conversation to one person and a handover to the other.

Yes, and you can choose a version between those extremes. 'I'm happy to tell you my guesses, but please don't confirm, deny or hint ahead' would give her a clear role if that is the conversation you'd enjoy.

Join the discussion

More in Funny