Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Neighbours · Advice & Questions ·

How do I ask for a firm dinner reply when my neighbour wants to keep her options open?

Neighbours category photographNeighbours

I invited a neighbour to dinner and she replied, 'I'd love to.' I understood that as accepting. When I mentioned shopping for the meal, she said she would confirm on the day because some friends might invite her out.

She says she wasn't promising anything until she knew their plans. I can accept that we understood her reply differently. I don't want to keep a place and prepare food while she waits to see which evening she prefers.

How can I ask for a firm answer before I shop without sounding as though I am making her rank her friendships? I am happy to hear no. If she can't decide by then, I would rather plan this dinner without her than stay annoyed about an arrangement we never clearly agreed.

Discussion

5 community replies

Give her the planning deadline and the choice it creates: you need a definite answer before shopping, and if she can't confirm you'll plan without her this time. There is no need to debate which invitation she values more.

'I'd love to' conveyed something firmer to you than she intended. Acknowledge that misunderstanding once, then make the next question explicit. Asking 'Shall I count you in?' is clearer than assuming enthusiasm is a final answer.

I wouldn't ask for more detail about the other friends or try to persuade her your meal will be better. The issue is whether you can plan around her attendance, not whether she has a good enough reason to hesitate.

If you sometimes have room for an extra guest at short notice, could you leave open the possibility of checking again on the day?

Only if that flexibility actually suits this meal. The poster has said the uncertainty affects shopping and preparation. A last-minute place can be an occasional offer, but it shouldn't quietly become another commitment to hold a seat open.

Join the discussion

More in Neighbours