Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Career / Work · Advice & Questions ·

How candid should I be in an exit interview described only as confidential?

Career / Work category photographCareer / Work

The exit-interview form asks for “complete honesty” and says the conversation is confidential. It doesn't say who will read the notes.

I'm leaving because I repeatedly received conflicting priorities, then was criticised for the work that slipped. I've tried discussing that with my manager and don't think another conversation with them would help. HR has now asked for examples.

I can give specific examples without attacking anyone. I'm less willing to hand over a long account if it will simply be forwarded to my manager as my farewell message. I also don't want to invent a cheerful reason for leaving.

What would you establish about the interview before deciding how much to share?

Discussion

5 community replies

Ask what “confidential” means in this process: who receives the notes, whether comments are attributed and how examples are used. You don't have to supply your most detailed account before you understand the audience.

A truthful short answer is available: the recurring conflict over priorities was a reason you decided to leave. You can state that without recounting every difficult exchange. Detail should serve a point you want understood, rather than prove that leaving was justified.

Choose examples that show the pattern clearly: the two priorities, what you asked, the answer and the later criticism. That gives HR something more useful than a description of your manager's personality. Include what you actually know, rather than colleagues' accounts of similar problems.

If everyone gives a polite sentence and leaves, HR may never understand how bad the coordination has become. There is a cost to saying very little too.

There is, and that may be a reason to give a concise, specific account. It still doesn't require unrestricted disclosure. After clarifying how the feedback will be used, choose what you're willing to stand behind and share; don't let the form's request for complete honesty turn into an obligation to recount everything.

Join the discussion

More in Career / Work