Real people. Real opinions.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Education · Advice & Questions ·

How can I take part in a seminar when I think of my response after everyone has moved on?

Education category photographEducation

By the time I had found the paragraph I wanted, the discussion had moved to the next chapter. At the end, the tutor said, "You need to contribute more; participation is part of the mark."

I do the reading and usually write a page of notes. In a room of sixteen people, three students answer almost immediately. I wait for a gap, then worry that my point will drag us backwards. Last week I finally interrupted and repeated something someone had already said.

I don't want a mark just for being present, and I do want to get better at speaking. Would it be reasonable to ask for a moment to bring in a prepared passage, or to ask whether a short written response could count towards the discussion? I can show the tutor the question in my notebook. Showing it to everyone feels like another task entirely.

Discussion

4 community replies

I'd bring that particular notebook question to the tutor and explain when you wanted to ask it. That gives them something concrete to respond to, rather than asking them to decide whether you are a 'quiet student' who deserves an exception.

A prepared contribution needn't be a polished speech. 'I read this passage differently because...' could be enough to enter the discussion. You can ask about a way to practise that without requesting that speaking disappear from the course.

Have you seen the participation criteria? They might distinguish preparation, listening and responding, or they might specifically assess spoken discussion. Knowing what is being marked would make the written-response request clearer.

The three fast responders are part of the classroom pattern too. A tutor could try a pause for everyone to find a passage before opening the discussion, rather than leaving you to win an interruption contest.

Join the discussion

More in Education