Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

How can a former civic-group chair help without answering for the new chair?

Politics category photographPolitics

Our new civic-group chair pauses to check the agenda before answering procedural questions. The former chair usually jumps in with the answer, and people have started directing questions straight to her. She says she's only saving the new chair from embarrassment.

The information is often useful. The effect is that the new chair hardly gets to conduct the meeting. I'd like us to agree a way for the former chair to offer help without making every hesitation a handover back to her.

Should the new chair address this privately first, or clarify the arrangement in the room? Nobody wants to shame a willing volunteer, and nobody wants an avoidable procedural mistake to go uncorrected.

Discussion

5 community replies

Try a private agreement first: let the chair answer or ask for help, with the former chair available for a quiet prompt. That preserves the useful knowledge without making interruption the default.

The group has a role too. If members elected a new chair but keep addressing the old one, this isn't only a matter of one person learning to wait.

A pause to check isn't necessarily embarrassment. The former chair may be solving a problem that the new chair doesn't actually have.

I wouldn't want 'wait to be asked' to mean staying silent while the meeting takes a seriously wrong procedural step.

Nor would I. Agree a brief way to flag a genuine problem, such as 'Can we check the rule before deciding?' That is different from answering every routine question first. The distinction lets the new chair lead while the group still benefits from experience.

Join the discussion

More in Politics