Stories. Questions. Different perspectives.
Browse WAURE
← Advice & Questions
Politics · Advice & Questions ·

Does winning the most votes nationwide automatically decide a US presidential election?

Politics category photographPolitics

I'm helping edit a basic civics handout. One sentence says, 'The US presidential candidate with the most votes across the country wins.' Someone wants to keep it because an explanation of the Electoral College would take too much space.

The National Archives' account explains that presidential voting involves choosing electors, who then vote for president and vice president, followed by the counting of electoral votes in Congress. A nationwide popular-vote total is not, by itself, the rule that awards the presidency.

I don't want to overload a beginner's handout with every contingency. But keeping a simple sentence that gives the wrong deciding rule seems worse than adding a few lines. What is the shortest useful explanation that also avoids giving the impression that people's ballots have no role?

Discussion

5 community replies

You need the electors in the explanation. 'Voters choose electors through their state's presidential election; electoral votes determine the outcome under the Electoral College process' gives the reader the basic connection.

I'd remove the incorrect sentence even if you can't fit a full replacement beside it. Simplicity should help someone build the next piece of understanding, rather than force them to unlearn the first one.

Don't turn the correction into 'the popular vote doesn't matter'. That sounds as though voters are absent from the process, when your source explains how their votes connect to selecting electors.

What if readers then ask why a candidate's national vote total is reported at all? The handout could seem to contradict the coverage they see.

Say that a national total can describe overall voter support without being the rule that selects the president. That answers the immediate puzzle. You can leave the arguments for and against the system for a different part of the discussion.

Join the discussion

More in Politics